Main Site
FTP Site
What's New?
Contact Info

Home
Drivers & Utils
BIOS
Troubleshoot
FAQs
Other Links
virtual edge

Last revised:
01/10/2000

Intel Celeron and Pentium III FC-PGA Performance
Intel Celeron and Pentium III FC-PGA Performance Part 2
page 1 of 2

Intel Pentium III FC-PGA In part 1 of our Celeron and Pentium III FC-PGA performance comparison, the motherboard we used was based on the Intel 810 chipset. This time, let's take a look at the performance results for an Intel 810E motherboard.

The first generation Intel 810 chipset was really designed for the Celeron processors. Because of this, the 810 front side bus (FSB) was limited to 66/100MHz. The Intel 810E (E for enhanced) removes this limitation by allowing the FSB to run at 66/100/133MHz.

In addition to the faster FSB, the Intel 810E chipset will support both the socket 370 PPGA (plastic pin grid array) and FC-PGA (flip chip-pin grid array) form factor. The PPGA is the form factor used by today's Celeron processors. But for the Pentium III Coppermine processors, Intel will use their new FC-PGA socket 370 form factor instead (see picture above). The FC-PGA allows Intel to reduce cost and the processor's thermal output. Intel will also be migrating their Celeron line to this new FC-PGA form factor.

The primary difference between the PPGA and FC-PGA form factor is the voltage requirement. Most Intel 810 based motherboards are designed with the PPGA voltage requirement; therefore, those motherboards will NOT BE ABLE TO USE THE FC-PGA PROCESSORS (BE IT PENTIUM III COPPERMINE OR CELERONS). There are some exceptions because some motherboard manufacturers may modified the voltage requirement on Intel 810 based board to accomodate the FC-PGA processors. But in most cases, it's best to use a board based on the Intel 810E chipset instead; because you get support for the 66/100/133MHz FSB.

For review, below is the table that shows the features of each processor:

Features Celeron Coppermine
Front Side Bus 66MHz 100/133MHz
L1 Cache64K 64K
L2 Cache128K 256K
L2 Cache SpeedFull CPU Speed Full CPU Speed
MultimediaMMX MMX/SSE
InterfaceSocket 370 Slot 1
Socket 370
Micron0.25 0.18
Maximum Speed533MHz 600+MHz

The maximum speed of each processor is as of 11/30/1999. Intel will no doubt be ramping up the speed in the near future.

Let's look at the performance comparison between the socket 370 Celeron CPUs and the socket 370 Pentium III "Coppermine" processor. Here is the the test system configuration:

Component Celeron/Pentium III System
Motherboard PREMIO CS2
Chipset Intel 810E
Memory Kingston 64MB PC133 SDRAM DIMM
BIOS Version Award version 1.5B4 - 11/01/1999
HDD Western Digital 27GB 7,200RPM ATA-66 (WD273BA)
Video Intel Direct AGP (4MB buffer)
Operating Systems Windows 98SE and NT 4.0 Workstation SP5

The following table summarizes the Celeron and Coppermine Pentium III FC-PGA processors used in this test. (Officially, the fastest Pentium III FC-PGA is 550MHz, as of 11/30/1999; unofficially, it's possible to overclock the CPU up to 700MHz for benchmarking purposes ONLY.):

Processor L2 Cache Front Side Bus (FSB)
Celeron/366 128K 66MHz
Celeron/400 128K 66MHz
Celeron/433 128K 66MHz
Celeron/466 128K 66MHz
Celeron/500 128K 66MHz
Celeron/533 128K 66MHz
P3/500 FC-PGA 256K 100MHz
P3/550 FC-PGA 256K 100MHz
P3/600 FC-PGA 256K 100MHz
P3/650 FC-PGA 256K 100MHz
P3/700 FC-PGA 256K 100MHz

Ziff-Davis Winstone 99 measures overall system performance by running through a series of commonly used business and engineering applications. Likewise, Winbench 99 measures the performance of a specific part of the system; such as video or hard disk drive performance. Higher numbers are better.

Winstone 99 Business/98SE
The graph above shows the relative performance between the Celeron 366-533MHz CPUs (orange bars) against the Coppermine Pentium III at 500-700MHz (green bars). The test suite is Winstone 99 under Windows 98SE. As expected, due to the larger L2 cache and higher clock speeds, the Pentium III CPUs easily beat the Celeron processors. Even the PIII/500 FC-PGA is faster than the higher clock speed Celeron/533.

Winstone 99 Business/NT
Under Windows NT 4.0 workstation, the performance gap between Celeron and Pentium III is even greater. This is due to the fact that the NT applications are more CPU intensive than those tested under Windows 98SE.

Next